Potential benefits are many. Programmatic offers:
No wonder advertisers and publishers are jumping on board so fast. But with every silver lining, there always seems to be another cloud about to come in…
Programmatic is growing in leaps and bounds, expanding beyond desktop display ads and moving to rapidly to mobile, video, radio, television and even to print.
US dominates the market today, spending alone in programmatic advertising reached US$10bn in 2014 and is forecasted by to reach $15bn by next year.
Some analysts have gone so far as to predict that 90 per cent of US advertising will be bought programmatically by 2017. This is an amazing forecast considering the Association of National Advertisers (ANA) discovered through a survey last year that only 26 per cent of its members even knew what programmatic was and used it.
In the rest of the world, reasons for slower uptake tend to be related to the use of personal data and regulations concerning the internet. In Europe, uptake varies by country for different reasons, such as their adherence to established business practices; but the continent is definitely catching up, with the UK in the lead.
The only thing I know that grows that fast is a tidal wave.
Did you know that for every dollar invested by an advertiser using programmatic buying, only about 40 cents goes to the publisher? The supply chain for programmatic is long and complicated and with every step along that chain, money gets distributed.
Trading desks, data management platforms/systems, exchanges, ad servers, networks and agencies all get a piece of the programmatic pie.
So is programmatic really the holy grail for publishers? One begins to wonder when the dark (cloudy) side of programmatic rears its ugly head. And perhaps the ugliest of all, is…
Today over half of all digital ads displayed never reach the eyeballs of human beings, but they still generate “false impressions” that cost advertisers billions every year, while padding the pockets of publishers.
Ad fraud is rampant within the industry and it’s only a matter of time before advertisers start demanding more transparency into the viewability of their ads on publishers’ digital properties. If publishers thought today’s digital dimes were a sad replacement for print’s dollars, imagine what they’ll think when they’re knocked down to mere programmatic nickels.
Ad fraud comes in many forms from outright corruption among impression/click thieves to ad fraud apathy among publishers who aren’t prepared to give up their fraudulent funds, to helpless ad agencies who don’t have the power to fix it and finally to brands that aren’t fully aware of its impact on them.
In traditional advertising with higher price tags, these issues would not be left unaddressed. But in the digital world where advertising is so cheap, it’s like playing penny slots – there’s low pain on the investment side even if there’s not much gain in terms of ROI. So why make a fuss?
Never one to sugar-coat his opinion, Ad Contrarian and renowned speaker, Bob Hoffman put it this way, "Everything about online advertising is corrupt... The promises are corrupt. The data is corrupt. The suppliers are corrupt. And the buying and selling is corrupt...This industry is in desperate need of investigation."
In an attempt to win the war on ad fraud industry leaders have banded together to launch the Trustworthy Accountability Group (TAG). This is a noble first step to try and eliminate fraudulent traffic, combat malware, fight internet piracy and promote transparency, but will TAG become just another bureaucratic audit bureau?
The over-commoditisation of low quality ads threatens both brands and publishers alike. In the past, filler ads in printed editions helped balance out the layout of newspapers and magazines with reasonably good affect. In the digital world however, filler ads do not add the same value in terms of visual esthetics; in fact they seriously degrade it.
In addition, media buyers receive little to no guarantees from publishers in terms of brand protection. Despite all the big smart data being used to target ads personally and contextually, “mess ups” can happen, such as an all-inclusive vacation package ad displaying in close proximity to a story about a plane crash, or a feminine hygiene product ending up on men’s magazine home page. Even pornographic ads have slipped through website filters.
These blunders are more common than one might think and they happen often without publishers and advertisers even noticing. But the scary part is that consumers do and they’re taking action. Which brings us to the next pitfall of programmatic – an over-abundance of poor quality ads polluting websites and popularising the use of…
Ad blocking may be seen as a curse by publishers, but it’s actually a cry for help from consumers. It’s a desperate move by website visitors to create a better digital experience for themselves. If publishers won’t do it for them, users have only two choices – abandon the site or block the advertising.
Print fashion magazines have often been heralded as the poster children for beautiful and engaging, glossy ads. Their quality-over-quantity approach addresses both user experience and higher monetisation objectives. Why can’t this same “quality first” mentality be transferred onto the web?
If you want people to pay for content, you need to provide them as good an experience as they receive in your printed edition. Just because your website is built with bits and bytes doesn’t mean what’s on display (content and ads) shouldn’t be as desirable and beautiful as its physical counterparts.
The explosive growth of programmatic is both amazing and scary at the same time. It’s become the new shiny tool for publishers looking for a quick buck and advertisers wanting effortless access to inventory.
But what started out as an easy way to publish banner ads has turned into a hammer looking for another nail – the most recent being native advertising.
The trend towards automating advertising across all mediums makes one wonder when all content will be swept up by the programmatic wave and be crafted, curated and consumed programmatically.
Sounds a bit crazy now, but then again, if 10m self-driving cars can be on the road by 2020, programmatic news will be writing about them. The question is when.
When will machines replace editors, deciding what content should be presented to readers based on “their big data”? When will magazine content be created by computers just commodifying articles, ads, video and imagery from around the web and then auctioned off to the highest Real Time Bidder named News-bot?
More like this
With Facebook and Google predicted to take half of the World’s total digital ad-spend in 2017, it’s no surprise that other players in the industry have raised concerns. But by updating their own data offerings to better reflect advertisers needs, media owners can keep pace with changing digital trends.25th Aug 2017 Opinion
If I were to ask you to describe the Internet of Things (IoT), I expect many of you would start to talk about how new technology is revolutionising the internet, providing “anything connectivity” through advanced networks, sensors, electronics, and software. And you wouldn’t be wrong.24th Aug 2017 Opinion
In her previous blog post, SPH Magazines' Hafizah Hazahal shared how the Google/Youtube ‘brand safety’ chaos has led to the industry’s reawakening to the importance of branding, vis-à-vis the pursuit of conversions in this digital age. When it comes to branding, a study by Magnetic Media has proven that magazine media excels in building “meaningfully different” brands which drives repeat purchase and grow market share.11th Aug 2017 Opinion
Challenging times have led businesses to be obsessed with chasing conversions… which can be at the expense of the brand. Just look at what happened in the recent chaos which saw many brand owners freezing their adspend on Google and Youtube, following the realisation that their ads are appearing alongside offensive content on these platforms.4th Aug 2017 Opinion
Harvard Business Review last week launched their new bot on Facebook Messenger, building on their success with a similar bot on Slack. The aim is to increase the number people having regular, frequent interactions with HBR to ultimately have them subscribe and/or up loyalty.21st Sep 2017 Features
While the rise of digital has led many publishers to reduce their print offering, Dennis Publishing has continued to invest. Kerin O’Connor, chief executive of The Week at Dennis, explains how it’s found success with a print version of The Week for children – and what it can teach the industry about the future of print…18th Sep 2017 Features
As one of Europe’s leading publishing houses, Gruner + Jahr has been through a period of major transition. Julia Jäkel, CEO, sets out how the business has managed that, and outlines the path for the future…18th Sep 2017 Features
In his new role as group director of Haymarket Consumer Media, Alastair Lewis is ensuring that some of the UK’s most respected specialist magazine media brands are positioned to thrive in an international environment.25th Sep 2017 Features
Research by PwC indicates a strong trend towards money being spent on advertising aimed at kids under the age of 13 on all digital platforms. The kids digital advertising market could hit the $1.2 billion mark by 2019, then representing 28 per cent of all advertising directed at the youngest.18th Sep 2017 Insight News
Visit our Youtube channelFIND OUT MORE
FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the worldFIND OUT MORE
Get global coverage of your launches, company news and innovationsFIND OUT MORE
What’s happening now, what’s coming next