In the first nine months of 2015, supporters shelled out US$1.74m to support 173 journalism projects, on Kickstarter alone. This is a significant increase from the $49,256 raised for 17 projects in 2009, just six years prior. All told, from April 2009 to Sept. 2015, journalism projects launched on Kickstarter have received funding amounting to $6.3m.
Lined up against the $20bn in revenue generated by newspaper ads, Kickstarter’s sums may seem anaemic. Yet the funds and influence that Kickstarter —alongside a growing number of publicly funded journalism projects—represent is no small change, literally and figuratively.
Kickstarter is just one of a growing number of crowdfunding platforms, and one among several that are specifically focused on journalism. The Pew report notes: ‘In today’s evolving digital era, [crowdfunding] represents a new, niche segment of nontraditional journalism driven in large part by public interest and motivation.’
In short, it's a new chapter for journalism that offers a win-win-win. Win 1: Hungry, enterprising journalists, who are seeking the means to report on important and untold stories and push the envelope, are tapping into the financial resources to do so. Win 2: The public gets a seat in the editor’s chair to support the journalism, stories and topics they find meaningful. Win 3: Media organisations are dialing into quality and diverse content without the burden on their budget.
Last fall, an alternate plotline in the crowdfunding story began to crystalise. Beacon, an Oakland-based startup and crowdfunding platform, announced a $3 million campaign to fund stories focused on immigration. Subsequently, the San Francisco Chronicle announced its plans for a $15,000 multimedia reporting project titled ‘The Faces Behind the H-1B Debate’, covering immigration and the Bay Area tech industry. The Chronicle was calling on readers to fund the project and was the first newspaper to partner with Beacon. The Nation and ProPublica also joined the fray, alongside a number of other smaller independent outlets, to cover an angle of the immigration beat.
The Beacon campaign represents several shifts in the crowdfunding space. Top among them, the focus has shifted from individual journalists or journalism groups, to broad topics, ‘filling a gap in journalism’. Crowdfunded journalism is also getting, well, crowded. Established media outlets are taking more space, collaborating directly with crowdfunding platforms. One example is The Huffington Post raising $40,000 to transform a local citizen journalist into a dedicated reporter in Ferguson, MI, following the 2014 police shooting of Michael Brown.
Among Kickstarter projects alone, established media organisations and outlets now represent 22 per cent of funded journalism projects, which according to the Pew report, ‘have had a measure of success’. This prompts a closer look at how business models—with alternate revenue strategies and streams—might evolve in an era of diminishing ad dollars. Simply put, it’s an effective way to get readers to pay for news. But is there room to grow?
While there is plenty of hype around successes, journalism crowdfunding platforms have also had a measure of failure. Against this backdrop, Beacon’s immigration campaign underscores a savvy approach in the strategic repositioning of its funding model. After establishing itself in 2013 on a pay wall and subscription model, Beacon has redirected its efforts to center on partnerships and matching funds.
‘If I put in $100 to someone I know or a publication I trust and as soon as I pledge, I see that turn into $200,’ said Dan Fletcher, Beacon co-founder in Poynter.org. ‘I feel like I'm having more impact. This, Fletcher added, ‘is something readers are ultimately looking for’.
Some argue that the Pew report may generate a degree of unmerited hype around the role that Kickstarter has to play in publicly supported journalism. Through the Cracks: Crowdfunding in Journalism provides an inventory of standout journalism funding campaigns in 2015 beyond the Kickstarter universe, which quickly overtakes the $6.3 million raised to date. Clearly, there is room for greater innovation and new directions. One example is crowdfunded fact-checking. In the scramble to fund quality journalism and coverage of important topics, one mantra seems to hold true: engage, engage, engage. Crowdfunding is not going away.
More like this
As the internet pivots more and more towards visual content, VG.no, Norway’s largest online news site, is maintaining its position by investing significantly in one thing: online video.19th Mar 2018 Features
The relationship between publishers and platforms, and in particular Facebook, was never far from conversation at several sessions at FIPP and VDZ’s Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin today.19th Mar 2018 Features
In a world where content distribution has gone digital, we are witnessing the death of industrial marketing - paving the way for the Amazonification of media: a digital environment were the gap between inspiration and transaction will be closed down almost completely, says Troy Young, Global President, Hearst Digital Media, USA.19th Mar 2018 Features
Maureen Hoch, editor of Harvard Business Review’s HBR.org on Monday provided insight into the experimental work HBR has been doing with new media formats in the past year to reach and engage audiences, including subscribers, in new ways.19th Mar 2018 Features
When I look at the state of mainstream media, I can’t help but ask the question. Why are so many news publishers pivoting back to paywalls when they didn’t work for most of them before?12th Mar 2018 Opinion
While digital titles specialising in health and well-being are showing strong growth in developed markets such as Finland, the next step is to lead consumers from inspiration to transaction, and to go global, says new FIPP board member Kaisa Ala-Laurila, CEO of A-lehdet in Finland.12th Mar 2018 Features
“The notion that print is dead is not accurate. I think print isn’t dead, it’s just different. Gone are the times where you can operate with an inflated rate base or 12 times per year as a standard. And I think gone are the days too where you were just concerned with whether there was enough fax paper in the machine where you got all of your signed insertion orders back. Those days are behind us. But print for many companies, Bonnier included, is still profitable. It’s just not at the margins that we once enjoyed. And I feel strongly that brands that sit one or two in a category or vertical can thrive if managed correctly.” - Eric Zinczenko, CEO, Bonnier Corporation12th Mar 2018 Features
It’s been another year of rapid change and innovative publishers continue to assemble a quiver full of new solutions to drive their businesses forward – something that becomes apparent when you page through the new 2018/19 edition of Innovation in Magazine Media 2018-2019 World Report, launched today at Digital Innovators’ Summit (DIS) in Berlin.19th Mar 2018 Features
Publishers need to think again about why people spend time with their content. Is it getting attention because it deserves it, or just a lucky spin of the social media slot machine?12th Mar 2018 Opinion
Visit our Youtube channelFIND OUT MORE
FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the worldFIND OUT MORE
Get global coverage of your launches, company news and innovationsFIND OUT MORE
What’s happening now, what’s coming next