return Home

Programmatic will eat itself: the first-price auction will fuel a new digital advertising era

Sebastian Moesman ()

Header bidding has changed digital ad trading forever. Now it’s even putting pressure on a foundation stone of the industry itself – the second-price auction. That’s good news, since a move to first-price will not only bring a more transparent auction, but a more transparent industry.

Its adoption will create a ripple effect finally ending remnant-era practices, allowing trust to re-enter the ecosystem, expanding budgets to programmatic and ushering in a new age in digital advertising.

What’s causing the change?

The main problem with the programmatic auction, as it’s run today, is that it doesn’t allow advertisers to achieve the win rates they need to reach audiences at scale. This has always been a problem, but it’s being aggravated by header bidding which effectively creates a two-tiered auction system.

On the buy-side, buyers can’t select an optimal bidding strategy, so advertisers can’t achieve the win rates they need. On the sell-side, running multiple siloed auctions means that content providers are flying blind in terms of how much their inventory is worth. That’s undercutting the effectiveness of the entire marketplace.

Add to this the industry-old problem that the second-price auction leaves room for vendors to charge hidden fees, and anyone can see that making the shift to a first-price auction model will solve many issues.

However, it’ll also create a domino effect with far-reaching repercussions for the industry in the long-term. Its adoption will return trust to the advertising ecosystem in three significant ways:

Nowhere to hide

When the highest bid is the winning bid, any fees charged on top of that will have to be open and transparent. Ad exchanges and ad tech vendors will no longer be able to bury service fees before presenting buyers the final bill and before paying out content providers. This will finally bring to light vendors with business models based on remnant-era practices with take rates as high as 30 per cent. The result will be a more honest value chain where budgets are easier to track. This will give more confidence to both buy and sell-side as they can be sure that more value is flowing through the entire ecosystem, not just to a few shadowy middlemen.

True value for content providers and advertisers

In a first-price auction scenario, advertisers will have more confidence in the exchange, but content providers will also have clearer insight into what their inventory is worth. They can value their audience and create a more effective monetization strategy, and negotiate better deals with the buyers that need to connect with that particular audience.

Programmatic fulfil its potential: a predictive, stable marketplace for big budgets

Lastly, making the shift to a first-price auction will open up advertising budgets to embrace more programmatic trading. Now, the programmatic industry undercuts itself because it doesn’t allow advertisers to reach audiences at scale. A second-price auction can return a lower price at times. However, what large advertisers are looking for, through help of their media planning partners, is winning a large number of impressions at predictable cost. That means the certainty of achieving the win rates, and subsequently the audience reach, predicted in their media plans. Rather than giving a lower price at unpredictable reach, advertisers would have more confidence in a programmatic ecosystem in which the price is relatively high and stable. That’s something that the “you get what you pay for” first-price auction model can provide: a predictive, more reliable and stable marketplace.

Once that’s in place, advertisers will have the confidence to put large budgets behind programmatic, use data to automate trading and extract more value from the campaign. This will allow programmatic to finally fulfil its full potential.

digital advertising ()

How will programmatic eat itself?

In the short term, we’re moving into a phase where both auctions exist concurrently. Many players have started communicating to buyers the auction type that will most favourably support win rates, but this needs to be standard practice across the industry, with buy-side and sell-side both adapting their technology to a new auction model. However, these are growing pains. In the long-term, the adoption of the first-price auction, as it is intended, will allow trust to re-enter the ad tech ecosystem. More advertiser confidence will lead to bigger budgets and allow programmatic technology to spread its wings and move advertising into a new future. A future where programmatic isn’t a side-note in the advertising mix, but becomes synonymous with advertising itself.

 

More like this

[Video] BurdaForward: programmatic selling beats direct sales

Programmatic doesn’t pay off

[Congress speaker Q&A] Still plenty of opportunity in digital advertising – Flipboard exec

Search, social, and media: where do publishers sit in a modern digital advertising campaign?

Zenith: 67 per cent of digital display to be sold programmatically by 2019

  • Capitalising on the 'content + community + commerce' trifecta

    Back in 2014, Mary Meeker’s annual Internet Trend Report carried the theme of “re-imagining” throughout her presentation - from messaging and communications to services and money. When she spoke about re-imagining verticals, she shared how more and more companies are adopting an internet trifecta where success is defined as a combination of a critical mass of content + community + commerce.  

    19th Jul 2019 Opinion
  • The real reason why newspapers are losing to Facebook

    There’s a major problem facing communities everywhere — local news is losing the competition for advertisers to the duopoly (Facebook and Google). These two firms account for around 70 per cent of all digital ad spending globally, which has forced closures and cutbacks and severely threatened the future of journalism.

    20th Jun 2019 Opinion
  • The Digital Edition's Quinceañero: 15 lessons over 15 years

    In November 2018, we co-hosted an Insider event with FIPP in Argentina and Chile about the role and value of digital editions. Given the Latin American venue, I decided to use a local coming-of-age tradition - a quinceañero -  the 15th birthday milestone when a girl transitions from a child into a young woman in the community.

    11th Apr 2019 Opinion
  • Turning your events data into valuable information

    The acceptance of the need to turn data into valuable information has reached a tipping point and will accelerate in the next three years, writes Thomas Howie, COO of events software platform Evessio.

    11th Feb 2019 Opinion
  • Print ‘thriving in wider publishing ecosystem’, finds UPM white paper

    Print continues to play a pivotal role in multi-platform, multi-channel strategies for publishers. This was one of the key takeaways from a presentation at FIPP Insider in Paris based on a UPM white paper on the future of media. 

    10th Oct 2019 Features
  • Low-friction models gaining traction to supplement magazine subscription strategies

    While magazine media has shifted to focus on reader revenue streams over the last 18 months or so, the landscape is still fraught with questions and uncertainties. No surprise then that subscriptions have been top of mind for media this year; the subject has been discussed at INMA's Subscription Summit, and snapshotted by FIPP's Global Digital Subscription Snapshot. 

    14th Oct 2019 Features
  • 10 startups solving key issues for media companies and magazine publishers

    The last few years have witnessed a renaissance in media focused startups. Powered by initiatives like Artificial Intelligence and blockchain, the new breed of companies have sought to answer some of the key issues that have dogged media and publishing companies for the past decade. How can they scale the amount of content they produce? How can they increase the number of people paying for it? And how best to harness social media to target new consumers and turn them into regular followers - and maybe even paying customers? Here, then, are ten new-ish companies that have all made great strides in their attempt to simplify the world of media.

    14th Oct 2019 Features
  • Chart of the week: Subscription is the main source of revenue for UK TV

    After surpassing advertising earnings nearly 15 years ago, subscriptions remain the top source of revenue for the television industry in the UK, according to Ofcom estimates. Growth in this arena remains strong and consistent, though online profit is accelerating at a breakneck pace.

    14th Oct 2019 Insight News
  • How to innovate

    In the fast-changing publishing world, every business is looking to innovate. But getting it wrong can cost money and leave you trailing behind the competition. In advance of a major session on innovation at the forthcoming FIPP World Media Congress, a selection of experts, including speakers Martha Stone Williams and Robin Govik, offer tips for harnessing innovation in your business.

    16th Oct 2019 Features
Go to Full Site