return Home

Five big questions for publishers in 2016

Towards the end of last year, our crew at HBR.org started to wonder whether Facebook’s Instant Articles would be a good fit for us to try. Sure, scads of newspapers had jumped aboard FB Instant—the Washington Post was among the most noticeable. And, why not? FB renders articles as advertised, instantly— making for a delightful mobile experience. 

But does it make sense for the Harvard Business Review when our strategy is about building a deeper (direct) relationship with our readers? Of course, pondering this question just lead me to bigger questions.  Eventually, the FB debate internally had triggered five other really big questions about our publishing future: 

  1. Should publishers even try to be technology players?
  2. What happens when your audience spends more time with your content somewhere else online?
  3. What happens to bundling print and digital?
  4. Can paid content models work within Facebook’s walls?
  5. Why isn’t this just AOL all over again?

But I won’t try to tackle each of these ideas this week; instead I’d rather role them out one at a time over the coming months – and feel free to pitch your own big questions that might be on your agenda.

Let’s start with #1:

Should publishers even try to be technology players?

Ask your technology folks if they can make your articles render as rapidly as FB Instant Article. Chances are pretty good that it’s not going to happen. So, if FB blows us out of the water with their dazzling speed, is it even worth trying to compete on the technology front? Or should publishers just stick to content where we can be great? 

The Washington Post is one of those publishers that wants to compete on both fronts—not unsurprising, given their owner. My take is that when we talk about technology at a publishing company, we are really talking about two (very) different types of automation: There’s technology that powers the utility infrastructure versus the product experience. 

To get the difference, imagine a house. The locks on the doors, the wooden beams, the walls, and the light sockets are all part of the utility infrastructure, which is composed of common parts—most of which are commodities. Now think about how each room is decorated, from the sconces to the furniture—this is all part of the distinctive product experience. 

A website is much the same. The login, the page structure, and search are all common utilities, versus the design of the page, animated graphics, and typeface, which are part of the experience. The first needs to function correctly, but the second must make your feel something.

When it comes to the latter — the part that makes you feel —Publishers must have the technology tools and expertise to differentiate their experience.  But a publisher gets very little credit for the utility infrastructure;  the utilities must work, but they won’t necessarily motivate your customer to come back on their own.

In his course on marketing strategy at the Harvard Business School, Professor Ranjay Gulati talks about “motivators” versus “hygiene factors.”  His example is a restaurant where the bathrooms are spotless but the food is so-so.  In this case, you aren’t apt to return.  But if the food is amazing and the bathroom is disgusting, it’s likely that you still won’t return.

You don’t motivate the customer with the clean bathroom, but you also can’t live without it. A website with a slick log in and fast pages but terrible content is not likely to get return visitors. Conversely, great content and a terrible log in experience is equally bad.

Gulati also notes that sometimes a motivator shifts to becoming a hygiene factor, as in the case of Volvo. Long ago, Volvo motivated consumers with their safety features, but as more and more cars jumped on the safety bandwagon with their own features—and the government mandated more and more of these sorts of features—Volvo’s motivator became a hygiene factor.

This may in fact be what’s happening with web publishing. Much of what we thought motivated users in the beginning, such as speedy pages, has now become a hygiene factor that you simply must have, but which won’t motivate a customer to become a loyal follower.

So, what does this mean in the context of Facebook’s speedy offering? Letting FB provide your content in their framework essentially helps them to motivate their customer to come back to them for the great content and a delightful experience. But if you see FB as a way to get your own new subscribers, you might come up short. And this would argue for giving FB some but not all of your content. It also means that when the customer does arrive at your digital offering that you motivate them with dazzling content. To do this, you must invest in the technology that is at the fingertips of the storytellers (the journalists, producers, marketers, etc) and keep the investment in the utilities under control. 

In other words, you want the door locks on your house to work without supporting a team of engineers to help greet every guest.

On to the next question: What happens when your audience spends more time with you somewhere else online?  It used to be that a healthy percentage of our audiences came from places like Google, Facebook, and Apple. But now, especially in the case of the Washington Post, which posts everything on FB, it’s entirely possible that at some point in the future our websites will be totally unnecessary. Is that a good thing or bad? Tune in next month….

Thanks and again don’t hesitate to email me questions or thoughts at jmacht@hbr.org or @machthbr on twitter. Happy to chat any time.

More like this

2016: It's make or break time for digital magazines

What publishers must know about content aggregation in 2016

Chris Llewellyn's 2016 magazine media predictions

  • Nordic warrior: transforming revenue models at Schibsted

    Norwegian-headquartered media giant Schibsted is often held up as a business that has transformed itself in recent years to remain relevant and thriving. Tor Jacobsen, SVP and chief consumer officer at Schibsted Media explains how the company has retained a focus on revenue generation during that transformation, and the role data is playing in driving growth.

    19th Jun 2019 Features
  • Finding a home at Penske Media, Rolling Stone 'poised to continue to tell world's most important stories... for decades to come'

    For over 50 years, Rolling Stone has been iconic in its coverage of music and popular culture, political journalism and commentary. From the Beatles' Magical Mystery tour to Shawn Mendes, Rolling Stone has covered the greatest rockstars, the hottest celebrities, the biggest political stories. Called a 'counterculture bible' by The New York Times, the magazine has launched careers, defined what was cool, inspired a rock song, been embroiled in controversy, and over the last two years, found a new home with Penske Media Corporation. 

    17th Jun 2019 Features
  • How to fix broken digital ad models

    Despite popular belief, subscriptions and paywalls will not be the silver bullet most digital publishers have been waiting for. Instead, publishers should be exploring innovation in digital advertising formats, said Jessica Rovello, co-founder and CEO, Arkadium, USA, at this year's Digital Innovators' Summit in Berlin. She proposed four new formats as a good place to start.

    17th Jun 2019 Features
  • American and European publishers learn from each other as advertising models converge

    In March, I attended the FIPP Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin and left with the realisation that advertising-related problems in Europe are the same ones we’re facing in America: media fragmentation, a failing business model, fraud, and the emergence of social platforms that distribute our content for free and control the ad spend.

    12th Jun 2019 Features
  • How The New York Times' AI-driven data insight tool is informing ad campaigns

    For publishers, AI-driven tools have largely been used for editorial purposes, to write articles on themes like sports scores, weather forecasts and real estate sales. For example, Reuters uses an AI-based tool called NewsTracer to sift through millions of tweets in real time, to flag potential news stories, for its journalists. UK-based Reach does something similar, using an AI-based tool called Krzana to monitor 60,000 online sources to alert journalists to breaking news, and Forbes has tested an AI-based tool to draft stories for contributors. Publishers have also leveraged artificial intelligence to power content recommendations, to edit homepages, and for translation.

    10th Jun 2019 Features
  • Finding a home at Penske Media, Rolling Stone 'poised to continue to tell world's most important stories... for decades to come'

    For over 50 years, Rolling Stone has been iconic in its coverage of music and popular culture, political journalism and commentary. From the Beatles' Magical Mystery tour to Shawn Mendes, Rolling Stone has covered the greatest rockstars, the hottest celebrities, the biggest political stories. Called a 'counterculture bible' by The New York Times, the magazine has launched careers, defined what was cool, inspired a rock song, been embroiled in controversy, and over the last two years, found a new home with Penske Media Corporation. 

    17th Jun 2019 Features
  • How to fix broken digital ad models

    Despite popular belief, subscriptions and paywalls will not be the silver bullet most digital publishers have been waiting for. Instead, publishers should be exploring innovation in digital advertising formats, said Jessica Rovello, co-founder and CEO, Arkadium, USA, at this year's Digital Innovators' Summit in Berlin. She proposed four new formats as a good place to start.

    17th Jun 2019 Features
  • A blueprint for successful change

    Martha Stone Williams, CEO of World Newsmedia Network, discusses how the media industry must adapt to embrace innovation, how data and measurement must be the cornerstone of strategy and direction, and successful media firms implement a culture of experimentation.

    10th Jun 2019 Features
  • Condé Nast International launches Vogue Business Talent

    Condé Nast International today announced the launch of Vogue Business Talent, a curated recruitment platform for professionals seeking opportunities with the world’s leading fashion brands. The new platform, launching with selected opportunities in London, New York, Paris, Milan and Hong Kong forms part of Vogue Business, the online B2B publication launched in January 2019.

    12th Jun 2019 Industry News
Go to Full Site