Less than a year later, Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg announced the abandonment of the company’s web app development for iOS declaring the use of HTML5 "one of the biggest mistakes, if not the biggest strategic mistake that we made".
And the winner of round one was…
In just 10 months the FT web app grew to more than two million users and continues to enjoy a 21 per cent increase in digital subscriptions year-on-year.
Meanwhile, Facebook became the most widely accessed app on mobile devices with 745m mobile users.
Two opposing choices in the app/mobile web debate – both successful. How’s that possible?
According to ComScore, in 2014, 86 per cent of mobile internet time was spent in native apps, validating Facebook’s favourite choice.
But hold on…the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) countered that consumers actually split their time 50/50 between apps and the mobile web, corroborating FT’s foresight.
Round one ends in a split draw
Native apps and the mobile web are both valid solutions, depending on what you’re trying to achieve.
The FT was focused on reducing the costs of cross-platform development and reliance on the restrictions device manufacturers impose on paid content apps such as:
The FT’s criteria was not a priority for Facebook; the social media giant was more interested in performance and features.
So in the end, both were right because their choices met their prime objectives.
Fast forward to 2015 and round two…
It’s been six months since HTML5 was officially blessed by W3C. One would think that it would be time to put the native/web app battles to bed and embrace the fully cross-platform technology that the publishing community has been waiting for since Apple launched the iPad in 2010.
But not so fast…
Last month, Ken Doctor of Newsonomics recommended that publishers look to mobile as a new source of revenue and focus on apps to turn to “readers – to subscribers – to members”. According to Doctor, publishers need to put more apps on smartphone screens.
Less than a week later, Monday Note’s Frédéric Filloux advocated adamantly that publishers should drop native apps and embrace the mobile web, mostly to save the escalating costs of cross-platform development.
Once again the battle lines are drawn, but this time it’s not between two distinctly different industries. Now experts in the publishing community are duking it out over digital edition technology.
After reading both posts, it occurred to me that something was missing from the conversation – the content. I submit that instead of focusing on the technology, publishers should be looking at how their content reaches readers:
In addition to these fundamental distribution requirements the content must also be easily discoverable and searchable, especially if one wants to attract the exploding population of mad men and women (i.e. millennials) who are far more likely to discover news by search than by brand.
In app stores it is very difficult to discover content unless you’re specifically brand-hunting because the content is not searchable. And even once you do discover and download a favourite magazine app, if you have implemented it using a flat, PDF-like Digital Publishing Suite (DPS) technology, you’re still out of luck – the text is just an image – not searchable, selectable or sharable.
But move content into an HTML5 browser and suddenly it becomes:
Easily discoverable by a larger audience of readers that may not be familiar with your brand or with editorial perspective
Fully-searchable for the growing number of readers who are more inclined to look for news by specific topics of interest
Going the distance
In addition to better discoverability and searchability, with HTML5:
Publishers can attract new readers through Search to increase brand awareness and drive traffic to web apps through both paid and non-paid channels
There is finally a single ecosystem, regardless of platform, that reduces a publisher's dependence on the limitations device manufacturers enforce on native apps with respect to content, pricing, user data processing and cross-platform subscription management
In 2014, for the first time ever, internet use on mobile devices exceeded desktop browsing, with 99.5 per cent of mobile users accessing content through smartphones and tablets. This trend is only expected to continue, which is good news for publishers looking to enjoy all the benefits HTML5 can bring to their digital properties.
As you may know, I’ve been an advocate and early adopter of HTML5 technologies since 2012 and believe that publishers should seriously consider all the opportunities web apps can bring to their digital properties. That being said, native apps are not dead.
Users have come to enjoy a number of benefits native apps provide them, including easy accessibility and single click-to-buy within app stores.
Publishers appreciate the brand presence app icons offer them on the mobile displays. However, today with HTML5, users can ‘bookmark’ a web app and have the brand appear as an icon on the screen for easy access in the future. This isn’t a common practice yet as it requires a bit of an end-user mind-set change, but once people catch on it won’t be long before they start saving their favourite web apps on their mobile displays.
Another reason users choose native apps over web apps for accessing content is the ability to download an issue and read it offline. In the past, this was not available outside of native apps, but those days are numbered.
Today small web apps can be cached for offline reading. This does not yet apply to digital replicas due to device and browser limitations, but when this capability becomes more pervasive across mobile technologies, it is destined to eliminate the need for content-based native apps and the long development cycles that go with the production and maintenance of multiple digital editions apps across desktops, tablets and smartphones.
HMTL5 isn't perfect, but it has come a long way in the past four years and its future is looking bright for the technology and for magazine publishers.
web/app battles are expected to continue for the next few years, with many publishers relying on hybrid apps as an interim solution that attempts to combine the best of both worlds.
More like this
“It’s finally time to end the Facebook addiction” shouts the headline to an Innovation in Magazine Media 2018-19 World Report chapter.28th Mar 2018 Opinion
Publishers need to think again about why people spend time with their content. Is it getting attention because it deserves it, or just a lucky spin of the social media slot machine?12th Mar 2018 Opinion
When I look at the state of mainstream media, I can’t help but ask the question. Why are so many news publishers pivoting back to paywalls when they didn’t work for most of them before?12th Mar 2018 Opinion
Good reporting is the life blood of any effective organisation. Clean data, clear reporting insight and right strategy are points on a continuum to maximum revenue. But today reporting has evolved to a swamp of endless possibilities, and not exactly a clear one. Add the fact that everyone uses different metrics and the frustration is complete.2nd Mar 2018 Opinion
Global president of Hearst Digital Media, Troy Young, opened the Digital Innovators Summit (DIS) in Berlin recently, in a presentation that looked at the future of lifestyle brands and the Amazonification of media. We caught up with Troy at the show to get some key insights from inside the global media brand.9th Apr 2018 Features
With both the dream of monetising reach and the digital advertising model going up in smoke for publishers, several speakers at this year’s Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin turned their focus to alternative revenue streams. Apart from subscription models, ecommerce received special attention.16th Apr 2018 Features
Innovation takes many forms. ForThe Netherlands's Libelle, innovation saved the 84-year-old brand as it encountered declining newsstand sales and subscriptions. For eleven of CNI's Vogues, innovative approaches to Instagram increased engagement and followers. For ALT.dk in Denmark, innovation meant turning Egmont Publishing's eight women's magazines into a one-stop digital destination for women. And, at Immediate Media's Olive magazine, innovation helped transform the small but mighty 15-year-old publication into a multi-platform brand. Each of these magazine media outlined their innovative approaches at the Digital Innovator’s Summit in Berlin.11th Apr 2018 Features
Robb Report launched a new brand for women that carves out a niche in the luxury women’s sector. The media brand, called Muse, will be printed bi-annually and live online at MusebyRobbReport.com.16th Apr 2018 Features
In a world where politicians are trying to regulate an environment they don’t understand, current European Union eprivacy regulations will not only deprive publishers of income but deteriorate the user experience for internet users, warned Oliver von Wersch, founder and CEO of Vonwerschpartner Digital Strategies in Germany during the recent Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin.13th Apr 2018 Features
Visit our Youtube channelFIND OUT MORE
FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the worldFIND OUT MORE
Get global coverage of your launches, company news and innovationsFIND OUT MORE
What’s happening now, what’s coming next