return Home

Test driving virtual reality in the newsroom

"We’re hacking into the audio and visual systems of your brain," director Chris Milk and co-founder of VR company, Vrse said to The New York Times just over a year ago regarding virtual reality projects. "A major part of journalism is painting people a picture of what it was like to actually be there. With this, the audience actually feels like they are there."

VICE VR ()

In the year that followed, it became increasingly clear that VR is pushing its way beyond the realm of sci-fi and gaming and into the mainstream. A few VR highlights over the last 12 months also indicate that Milk’s take on the relationship between VR and journalism, while complex, is crystalising. Immediately after introducing Sundance audiences to the Millions March in NYC, a VR journalism broadcast venture between directors Chris Milk, Spike Jonze and Vice News, Milk marched onto Davos to debut Clouds Over Sidra. The groundbreaking collaboration with the UN used VR to highlight the life of a Syrian girl in a refugee camp.

Google cardboard ()

Fast forward to November. An unassuming cardboard box—Google Cardboard—lands on 1.3 million US doorsteps in tandem with the Sunday New York Times. More recently, dispatches from the 2016 Sundance Film Festival describe the ‘boom’ in virtual reality, augmented reality and immersive films that include an extensive line-up of documentaries.

For the researchers, scientists, investors and engineers who have spent decades attempting to push VR across the finish line, this may look like the victory lap. On the sidelines, there are those cheering and eager to seize the storytelling opportunities this technology brings. Yet among them there are many—particularly from the newsroom—that are grappling with the implications of an emerging and highly elastic platform transforming to an established platform. 

Merging the Newsroom onto the VR Superhighway

There is a balance to be struck between the unparalleled potential of a highly compelling storytelling format and the practicalities and many implications that arise from a platform that spans diverse genres. At the same time, it’s time to lead, follow or get out of the way, according to Robert Hernandez, of the Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism at the University of Southern California. In his 2016 media forecast published in the Neiman Lab, the Harvard-based media innovation report, he asks, ‘Do news orgs get in early and risk the tech not working out? Or should they wait and let others define VR journalism and risk being left behind, again?’ His answer: Both.

The question then is, how? While journalists and media organisations are eager to get behind the wheel, there is broad consensus that there are no rules of the road. Taking practicalities and logistics into account, VR demands innovation, expertise, bigger budgets, flexibility and longer production lead time. The price of admission is going down, and Hernandez, echoed by others in the industry, cites 360-degree video as ‘the low-hanging fruit of VR’. Partnering with universities leading the charge and tapping into fresh student talent also may serve as a practical and efficient onramp to the VR track.

The New York Times has committed strategy and resources to make VR a viable journalistic tool. Their earnings released on February 4, showed net income of $52 million for the fourth quarter—a 48 percent increase over the same period in 2014—may point to efforts paying off.

‘We believe that our strategic approach—to rapidly build out new high value propositions for marketers in branded content, mobile, video and VR—is paying off,’ said Mark Thompson, the company’s chief executive said in an earnings call with investors.

The human connection: Proceed with caution

A constructed experience that inserts the user in the perceived present, VR is pushing the role of journalist and user into uncharted territory. Unexplored and unexpected implications await. The VR experience, as Milk described it, is ‘the ultimate empathy machine’. Yet what are the ethical responsibilities when it comes to broadcasting an unmitigated 360-view of the frontline of war or a terrorism event?

This question comes at a time when there is increasing buzz around the genre of ‘immersive journalism’, which brings a viewer, as a digital avatar, into a virtually recreated scenario, or news story. The figure who brought immersive journalism to the fore, Nonny de la Peña, former Newsweek correspondent, who co-founded, Emblematic Group, is playing an ever-greater role in shaping the future of VR-journalism.

De la Peña offered a new lens on the intersection of VR and journalism at the 2012 Sundance Festival with a piece called ‘Hunger in Los Angeles’, depicting a scenario where a diabetic man falls into a coma while waiting in line at a food bank. More recently, she’s delved into domestic violence and taken to the frontline of an abortion clinic.

Hunger in Los Angeles ()

Lined up against the more traditional long-narrative documentary format, de la Peña’s work prompts lively debate. And perhaps fittingly, she has been handed a key role in exploring best practices and charting next steps. With the support of a $580,000 Knight Foundation grant and in partnership with Frontline, Emblematic Group is collaborating on three virtual reality projects.

‘Our well-established editorial standards will guide us,’ writes Raney Aronson-Rath, executive producer for Frontline on the Knight Blog. ‘But virtual reality presents its own challenges, opportunities and questions. As we go forward in developing best practices, we will be consulting with Frontline’s network of producers, journalist colleagues in other news organisations and journalism schools.’

Increasingly a go-to journalism tool, VR is predicted to forge further into the mainstream and to go mobile. As for the rest—budget, production, innovations and content development and the parameters for it—the road sign mapping the way forward for journalism is as clear as it is confounding: it’s an arrow forward on top of a squiggly line: Read, sharp learning curves ahead.

More like this

Virtual reality could generate $70bn in real money by 2020

Virtual reality's time has arrived

Trends in media innovation – ways of storytelling with crowdsourcing and virtual reality

  • The difference between artificial intelligence and automation

    As the emergence of AI grows stronger, many have begun to conflate this technology with the previous wave of automation that has gone before it. Chris Boos, CEO and founder of Arago refutes this stance, and explains how publishers and other businesses are already practically applying artificial intelligence to their brands.

    17th Apr 2018 Features
  • When advertising goes… DIS focus on alternative revenue streams

    With both the dream of monetising reach and the digital advertising model going up in smoke for publishers, several speakers at this year’s Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin turned their focus to alternative revenue streams. Apart from subscription models, ecommerce received special attention.

    16th Apr 2018 Features
  • Muse: Robb Report's new brand targeting female readership

    Robb Report launched a new brand for women that carves out a niche in the luxury women’s sector. The media brand, called Muse, will be printed bi-annually and live online at MusebyRobbReport.com.

    16th Apr 2018 Features
  • Privacy, the EU and the future of publishers

    In a world where politicians are trying to regulate an environment they don’t understand, current European Union eprivacy regulations will not only deprive publishers of income but deteriorate the user experience for internet users, warned Oliver von Wersch, founder and CEO of Vonwerschpartner Digital Strategies in Germany during the recent Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin. 

    13th Apr 2018 Features
  • Hearst’s global president of digital on the evolution of lifestyle brands online

    Global president of Hearst Digital Media, Troy Young, opened the Digital Innovators Summit (DIS) in Berlin recently, in a presentation that looked at the future of lifestyle brands and the Amazonification of media. We caught up with Troy at the show to get some key insights from inside the global media brand. 

    9th Apr 2018 Features
  • When advertising goes… DIS focus on alternative revenue streams

    With both the dream of monetising reach and the digital advertising model going up in smoke for publishers, several speakers at this year’s Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin turned their focus to alternative revenue streams. Apart from subscription models, ecommerce received special attention.

    16th Apr 2018 Features
  • How women's magazines innovate

    Innovation takes many forms. ForThe Netherlands's Libelle, innovation saved the 84-year-old brand as it encountered declining newsstand sales and subscriptions. For eleven of CNI's Vogues, innovative approaches to Instagram increased engagement and followers. For ALT.dk in Denmark, innovation meant turning Egmont Publishing's eight women's magazines into a one-stop digital destination for women. And, at Immediate Media's Olive magazine, innovation helped transform the small but mighty 15-year-old publication into a multi-platform brand. Each of these magazine media outlined their innovative approaches at the Digital Innovator’s Summit in Berlin.

    11th Apr 2018 Features
  • Muse: Robb Report's new brand targeting female readership

    Robb Report launched a new brand for women that carves out a niche in the luxury women’s sector. The media brand, called Muse, will be printed bi-annually and live online at MusebyRobbReport.com.

    16th Apr 2018 Features
  • Privacy, the EU and the future of publishers

    In a world where politicians are trying to regulate an environment they don’t understand, current European Union eprivacy regulations will not only deprive publishers of income but deteriorate the user experience for internet users, warned Oliver von Wersch, founder and CEO of Vonwerschpartner Digital Strategies in Germany during the recent Digital Innovators’ Summit in Berlin. 

    13th Apr 2018 Features

Video

Visit our Youtube channel

FIND OUT MORE

SUBSCRIBE

FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the world

FIND OUT MORE

SHARE YOUR NEWS

Get global coverage of your launches, company news and innovations

FIND OUT MORE
Go to Full Site