On Monday, Facebook launched Portal, a brand new hardware product designed to facilitate consumer conference calling. But on the back of the company’s biggest ever data breach, criticism of the device has already been high.
For a full look at Facebook Portal in action, check out this video article from the BBC’s Silicon Valley correspondent, Dave Lee.
But for the purposes of time, let’s explain the product in this way: it’s a physical video calling device designed to evolve home communications beyond the likes of Echo Show or standard FaceTiming on your iPhone. It boasts the latest HD and AI technology, and there are two versions available – a 15 incher priced at US$349, and a 10 incher at $199. The artificial intelligence means that the camera follows you around room, making for an altogether more frivolous video calling experience than say an iPad, which without the AI bells and whistles is effectively what this new device is.
On the surface of things, this looks like a smart move. We’ve talked many times in recent months about the need for media companies to invest in physical world platforms, be that in the shape of events and experiences, or through tangible products such as the Apple iPhone, Amazon Alexa, or Nintendo Switch.
And certainly for Facebook, a company which incurred the biggest single day loss in US stock market history in July while iPhone-sale aficionado Apple was busy becoming a trillion dollar company, shifting a few physical units could well prove to be a useful way to stabilise the stock price, at least in the short-term.
Still, there’s no getting away from the fact that this particular product feels slightly bereft of innovation. Is it just an iPad with a swanky camera? Maybe. And for a company that has longsince built its name on digital advancements, jumping onto the physical hardware bandwagon at this stage feels a little, well, old skool. With software now available to facilitate video conferencing on pretty much any existing screen you can think of, why invest in the hardware of another one?
The Facebook bet on Portal appears to be being made on its advanced camera technology, and that raises a second problem.
TechCrunch reported the story yesterday under the headline, ‘Facebook, are you kidding?’ The sub-head was even more telling:
Facebook, champion of bad timing
As many users are looking for ways to compartmentalize or scale back their reliance on Facebook, the company has invited itself into the home. Portal is voice activated, listening for a cue-phrase (in this case “Hey Portal) and leverages Amazon’s Alexa voice commands, as well. The problem is that plenty of users are already creeped out enough by Alexa’s always-listening functionality and habit of picking up snippets of conversation from the next room over. It may have the best social graph in the world, but in 2018 people are looking to use Facebook for less — not more.
At a time when Facebook is still cleaning up the debris from the biggest data-breach in the company’s history, and Mark Zuckerberg is being paraded around Congressional hearings for all the world to see, an in-home Facebook video camera/voice activated device has been instantly met with privacy concerns. The brand is just not where it used to be.
Which is where the two main issues with Facebook Portal converge. In an age when people are looking to use Facebook and wider social media platforms less, the company’s attempt to invite itself round for a chat and a cup of tea in your living room for the rock bottom price of $199 (the latest iPhone is so far being touted round about the $1,000 mark) we are arguably now reaching a tipping point in the perception of the company from intimidating, to desperate.
Physical unit sales should mean a supple short-term revenue stream for the Facebook share-price, and right now Mark Zuckerberg knows that is what he needs to keep investors interested. But this is definitely the playing of a ‘Get out of Jail Free’ card by a company that is now in the Yahoo, rather than the Snapchat stage of its development. Ultimately, throwing an upgraded iPad at the situation is not going to be enough to save the brand, privacy concerns or no.
More like this
Back in 2014, Mary Meeker’s annual Internet Trend Report carried the theme of “re-imagining” throughout her presentation - from messaging and communications to services and money. When she spoke about re-imagining verticals, she shared how more and more companies are adopting an internet trifecta where success is defined as a combination of a critical mass of content + community + commerce.19th Jul 2019 Opinion
There’s a major problem facing communities everywhere — local news is losing the competition for advertisers to the duopoly (Facebook and Google). These two firms account for around 70 per cent of all digital ad spending globally, which has forced closures and cutbacks and severely threatened the future of journalism.20th Jun 2019 Opinion
In November 2018, we co-hosted an Insider event with FIPP in Argentina and Chile about the role and value of digital editions. Given the Latin American venue, I decided to use a local coming-of-age tradition - a quinceañero - the 15th birthday milestone when a girl transitions from a child into a young woman in the community.11th Apr 2019 Opinion
The acceptance of the need to turn data into valuable information has reached a tipping point and will accelerate in the next three years, writes Thomas Howie, COO of events software platform Evessio.11th Feb 2019 Opinion
For a long time lauded as the way to automate large parts of the industry, AI is, according to Lindsay Silver, VP of product at Condé Nast, finally coming of age – and AI 2.0 will have plenty to offer beyond simply taking tasks away from the editors.15th Aug 2019 Features
Liz Vaccariello is editor-in-chief of Parents magazine at Meredith Corporation. Here, she explains how taking a practical approach to innovation has helped the brand to evolve, and why a digital mindset can also hold great benefits for a print publication.19th Aug 2019 Features
The first round of recipients of grants to fund community journalism, paid for by Facebook, was announced on 17 July with a second round of grants also announced in the US. While many are happy as grants of up to US$25,000 remain up for grabs, others remain skeptical about the social media giant’s intentions.12th Aug 2019 Features
Cosmopolitan South Africa’s August cover star will be part of an exciting line-up of media and brand experts who will discuss the secrets of successful collaboration in spotlighting brands in magazine media at this month’s FIPP Insider events in South Africa.12th Aug 2019 FIPP News
On average global internet users spent 2 hours and 23 minutes on social media per day, though trends differed widely by country. In around half of the markets that Global Web Index surveyed, social media use had shrunk or plateaued in Q1 2019 when compared with 2018 figures.12th Aug 2019 Insight News
Visit our Youtube channelFIND OUT MORE
FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the worldFIND OUT MORE
What’s happening now, what’s coming next