return Home

Advertising transparency and trust: the case for independent verification of audience data

Glenn Hansen ()

In today’s ultra-competitive marketplace where media buyers are being held ever more accountable for buying decisions, margins and best industry practices, there is the danger that they may be relinquishing control of the process. This while those selling advertising solutions may be offering promises they cannot deliver. This begs the question, writes BPA Worldwide’s Glenn Hansen in this piece for FIPP: What traits and behaviours does the next generation marketer need to survive and thrive?

The answer is simple: transparency and trust – the two words which are heard more frequently now than ever before. There has been a shift of marketing spend in recent years to digital channels which, through technology, has given the marketer multiple measurement metrics which were not available in other forms of media. However, transparency and trust have not walked in step with the advancement in technology.

Consider the example of Facebook, which reported discrepancies with its ad measurement. I believe advertisers regarded the social media giant as simply too big to be incorrect, while Facebook continued to cultivate those old-school “trust me” relationships with advertisers. 

laptop mobile ()

Marc Pritchard of Procter & Gamble is known for infamously calling out Google and Facebook’s “walled gardens” and demanding transparency from the digital supply chain. Pritchard concluded. "It's time we come together to solve these problems," he said. "Let's realise the enormous potential of this amazing industry."

Keith Weed at Unilever joined the competitor, P&G, in the call for greater trust and transparency in adland. Improved viewability and metrics that mean something and are industry-wide are what is needed. In the UK in the meantime The Times exposed brand safety issues, where advertisers were inadvertently supporting terrorist groups by unknowingly advertising on their websites or videos.

With so much technology at hand, how could marketers not possibly understand or question their digital supply chain? 

The fact is the data was inaccurate and technology giants are still not adhering to industry best practices by allowing independent technology auditors to verify their systems. The industry placed trust and transparency without any reason for it to exist. 

It was the lack of oversight that allowed the situation to get to this point for advertisers. Metrics were being provided and they looked great, never questioned. But ads are not much use if they are viewed by non-human traffic, not relevantly placed when a human is on a website, or not viewable at all.

Now is the time for buyers to flex their muscles and stop investing precious advertising dollars until media platform owners – no matter how big or small – submit their processes and data to independent audits.

Marketing is complex and fragmented. Technology and working practices have led to a lack of accountability and transparency. What I have learned from my time in this industry is that advertising performance needs to be measured and optimised so that ad budgets are put to the most effective use. More importantly than this, measurement needs to be verified externally, not by those selling solutions or those buying. If we can get back to this point, trust and transparency can return. 

Marketers need to ask questions and be more proactive.

• Demand agents provide transparency. 

• Demand accountability for advertising spend that your ads were viewable by a real qualified audience. Demand accurate metrics.

• Demand one universal measurement system to one set of standards. 

• Do not be afraid of the automation that is sweeping through the media landscape.

• Learn more about how agents’ systems work.

• Make sure these automated solutions work – and work properly. 

• Make sure those systems are independently third party verified to industry standards. 

• Take responsibility for ad spend decisions; do not abdicate to agents. If you do not do so, you do so at your own peril.

BPA Worldwide is an independent, industry-owned, auditor of media and ad technology platforms. We call on the marketing community to help us to help them in bringing back trust and transparency to the media industry.

Get involved. 

More like this

Call to the industry to help Facebook and Google shut off funding to publishers of fake news

Google’s ad placement headache (and why publishers may feel a touch of schadenfreude)

Google and Facebook now control 20 per cent of global adspend

Publishers on FB Instant Articles: like it, don’t like it, don’t know…

  • How can publishers thrive in challenging times?

    [Sponsored] Recently the WoodWing team traveled to London for the FIPP World Congress. For those of you who haven’t been lucky enough to attend yet, the FIPP World Congress is the largest and most high profile media event in the world. It brings together the world’s leading multi-platform media publishers and industry suppliers, to explore the latest trends and solutions.

    25th Oct 2017 Opinion
  • Are digital editions dead?

    Digital editions have been around for a long time, going all the way back to the late 90's. But in 2010 when the iPad hit the digital runway, publishers jumped on the tablet bandwagon faster than they could shout, “Hallelujah!”. The struggling publishing industry had found itself a saviour.  

    16th Oct 2017 Opinion
  • Publishers should re-emphasise their behavioural roots to take on Facebook and Google

    With Facebook and Google predicted to take half of the World’s total digital ad-spend in 2017, it’s no surprise that other players in the industry have raised concerns. But by updating their own data offerings to better reflect advertisers needs, media owners can keep pace with changing digital trends.

    25th Aug 2017 Opinion
  • How brands can capitalise on the experiential revolution

    If I were to ask you to describe the Internet of Things (IoT), I expect many of you would start to talk about how new technology is revolutionising the internet, providing “anything connectivity” through advanced networks, sensors, electronics, and software. And you wouldn’t be wrong.

    24th Aug 2017 Opinion
  • How subscriptions became a driver of profit at The Economist

    Subscriptions have become The Economist’s biggest income stream in the past seven years. Michael Brunt, chief marketing officer and managing director, circulation at The Economist explains how they managed to transform the 174-year old title’s circulation business into the biggest driver of profits.

    9th Nov 2017 Features
  • Do publishers and platforms really need one another?

    We speak to media and social media blogger, consultant and lecturer Adam Tinworth on the evolving relationship media brands have with social platforms.

    8th Nov 2017 Features
  • The state of brand licensing around the world

    Recently, there has been a period of time where there was somewhat of a slow-down in international brand activity as companies focused on shoring up their bases. However, this year we have seen an increasing number of reports surfacing about media companies adopting a more global outlook again – at least in certain segments. Does this mean a renewed focus on brand licensing, and in what form? And what is the outlook as we head into 2018?

    13th Nov 2017 Features
  • CDS Global and Zeddit announce tech partnership to help publishers grow print magazine subscriptions

    CDS Global and Zeddit announced a strategic technology partnership in the UK and Australia to provide advanced subscriber conversion capabilities for print magazine publishers. The partnership will focus on improving the conversion of visitors to magazine websites into subscribers for CDS Global clients.

    13th Nov 2017 Industry News
  • How Egmont is reaping rewards from creating

    One of the biggest drives for publishers in the past decade or two have been transitioning their print content to digital. For some it is all about maintaining the magazine's brand essence online, yet others have enjoyed success in amalgamating print publications to create new web first brands.

    13th Nov 2017 Features


Visit our Youtube channel



FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the world



Get global coverage of your launches, company news and innovations


Upcoming @ FIPP

What’s happening now, what’s coming next

Go to Full Site