Ok, we’re not as big as GE, but at HBR we certainly worry about our heritage and brand. The question is, How do we respect our brand’s identity, but keep trying new things to expand our options for tomorrow? No easy task. And we’re not the only ones facing it. This is the central problem for just about every publisher who once upon a time had a reputation in the old world and now wants a stake in the new.
Govindarajan has a wonderful analogy here. He says that a big established company is much like a tree with deep roots: “You never want to cut the roots because the tree will die. The roots are your heritage. But you also don’t want to be chained to the past.” For Govindarajan,
The approach seems to make a ton of sense, but for some reason it doesn’t work for everyone. Some companies appear to be more capable of unchaining themselves from the past than others. But why? My hunch is that it comes down to a sense of purpose.
For publications that still have a strong purpose fueling their editorial engines, change can be both scary and exhilarating. Scary because you worry about losing your identity, and yet exhilarating because there is a sense of freedom that comes with the thought of unchaining oneself from an idealised past. This dynamic—balancing a strong sense of who you are with who you want to become—sets the stage for the sort of measured experimentation that Govindarajan describes in his work.
I’ve seen first-hand how this approach can move an established organisation forward. At HBR, we’ve made progress with new digital elements by starting with small experiments that give us a broader indication of how things like interactive tools, bloggers, video, and infographics can enhance our mission online.
But we can all recognise when a publication has lost its way. No longer rooted in any rich soil, some publications tend to drift from one identity to another. I remember having this feeling when I was at Business 2.0 years ago. I suppose some may feel this way about the newsweeklies as well. When you’re drifting, it seems as though experimentation only exacerbates your problems, serving to confuse readers even further about what your brand really stands for.
Part of the genius in applying the Govindarajan approach is that you need to seek a balance between forgetting and borrowing. For those who lack a clear sense of what they do for their readers—what they do that no one else can do as well—they may have forgotten too much. In these cases, experimentation may just lead down a path to nowhere.
But there’s an even bigger issue at play here as well. It’s becoming tougher than ever for publishers who lack a clear sense of purpose to survive. The old tricks of luring a zillion eyeballs from Google and spinning them into gold from advertisers is becoming less and less viable. The reality is that if your digital activities don’t enhance your core reason for being, as well as expand your audience, you could be in real trouble down the road. You need both parts of the equation, not one or the other.
Innovation is certainly key for all of us going forward, and unchaining ourselves from the past is a worthy goal. But we also need a deeply rooted understanding of why the customer craves us in the first place. Without it, we may unlock our chains, but not much else.
More like this
Back in 2014, Mary Meeker’s annual Internet Trend Report carried the theme of “re-imagining” throughout her presentation - from messaging and communications to services and money. When she spoke about re-imagining verticals, she shared how more and more companies are adopting an internet trifecta where success is defined as a combination of a critical mass of content + community + commerce.19th Jul 2019 Opinion
There’s a major problem facing communities everywhere — local news is losing the competition for advertisers to the duopoly (Facebook and Google). These two firms account for around 70 per cent of all digital ad spending globally, which has forced closures and cutbacks and severely threatened the future of journalism.20th Jun 2019 Opinion
In November 2018, we co-hosted an Insider event with FIPP in Argentina and Chile about the role and value of digital editions. Given the Latin American venue, I decided to use a local coming-of-age tradition - a quinceañero - the 15th birthday milestone when a girl transitions from a child into a young woman in the community.11th Apr 2019 Opinion
The acceptance of the need to turn data into valuable information has reached a tipping point and will accelerate in the next three years, writes Thomas Howie, COO of events software platform Evessio.11th Feb 2019 Opinion
We are delighted to announce the 2019 Rising Star in Media winners!4th Nov 2019 Rising Stars
We are at the 42nd FIPP World Media Congress, taking place from 12-14 November. If you were unable to make it to Las Vegas, here are some ways you can follow the news and engage from where you are.11th Nov 2019 FIPP News
Bonnie Kintzer, CEO of Trusted Media Brands, USA, outlined the company's path to success over the last six years and the seven steps she now finds pertinent to transformation, during the opening session of the 42nd FIPP World Media Congress, taking place at Planet Hollywood in Las Vegas, 12 November.12th Nov 2019 Features
In line with the evolution of smartphones and tablets, the global mobile advertising market has been growing ever larger over the past decade.4th Nov 2019 Insight News
Contrary to what most magazine brands are trying to achieve, deliberately not developing a dedicated digital format for the iconic Monocle magazine remains part of the Monocle brand strategy, delegates to the 42nd FIPP World Media Congress in Las Vegas learnt.13th Nov 2019 Features
Visit our Youtube channelFIND OUT MORE
FIPP newsletters allow you to keep up with industry trends, research, training and events across the worldFIND OUT MORE
What’s happening now, what’s coming next